The US Department of Homeland Security has proposed a change to immigration rules that would end the requirement that USCIS give weight to its own earlier approval when reviewing a visa extension request. DHS has proposed removing the rule that tells USCIS to defer to its earlier approval when an employer files to extend a worker's status. The change would delete Section 8 CFR 214.1(c)(5) from the rules. According to the law firm Reddy Neumann Brown PC, the proposal is titled "Removing Deference to Prior USCIS Determinations of Eligibility" and was published on October 14, 2026. Public comments on the proposed rule were due Friday, November 13, 2026.
Under current 8 CFR 214.1(c)(5), when USCIS reviews a Form I-129 involving the same parties and the same underlying facts as a previously approved petition, it gives deference to its earlier decision. USCIS generally gives that deference when an employer files an extension for the same worker, job and underlying circumstances. Under the current regulation, an officer can depart from a prior approval only under specified conditions, such as a material error in the prior approval, a material change in circumstances or eligibility requirements, or new material information that adversely affects eligibility.
The proposed change could affect H-1B, L-1, O-1, TN, E and other work visa categories. DHS estimates that around 208,429 petitions filed each year could lose the benefit of deference to earlier approvals. DHS also estimates the change could result in around 6,044 additional requests for evidence every year. DHS says H-1B petitions make up more than 75% of all Form I-129 filings, a share the law firm Reddy Neumann Brown PC also cites.
DHS states that denial rates did not statistically differ between periods with and without deference, and its difference-in-differences analysis found no change in denials. The only measurable effect DHS found was more RFEs.
According to USCIS data cited by the law firm, Indian-born workers accounted for 77.6% of H-1B approvals for continuing employment in fiscal year 2025. According to DHS data cited by the law firm, 57% of employers classified as small entities that filed H-1B extensions in fiscal year 2025 were small businesses. H-1B workers who file an extension on time can generally continue working for the same employer for up to 240 days after their I-94 period expires while the application is pending.