The EU and the UK warned Kosovo MPs not to pass an amended law curbing the powers of the Kosovo Specialist Chambers without consultations with international allies. They also urged lawmakers to seek international advice as they review the amended law. Kosovo MPs are undecided on whether the bill in its current form is adequate.
Concerns from the EU and the UK
The EU Office in Kosovo said the amendments raise serious concerns about Kosovo's international obligations and compliance with basic rule of law principles. It named judicial independence, the protection of victims and witnesses, the continuity of procedural rights, and effective accountability in particular. In a Facebook statement, the EU said the amendments also raise concerns about their constitutionality and stressed the need for prior consultations before any adoption. The Specialist Chambers was established through an exchange of letters between Kosovo's President and the EU, making it an international agreement, so the EU requires consultations for any changes to its legal framework.
The British Embassy in Prishtina said it feared the proposed amendments will do nothing to serve Kosovo's essential interests and will undermine its relations with international partners and supporters. It encouraged MPs to take more time for further consultations internally and with the EU and other international allies to find a better solution.
Debate in parliament
On Thursday, at the Parliamentary Commission for Legislation, Vetevendosje MP Vigan Qorrolli argued that a redraft is needed. He said a new legislative initiative drafted with care and through joint parliamentary participation would be the most responsible way to address the issue. PDK MP Blerta Deliu-Kodra said that, after discussions with other parties, they agreed to pass the bill but there is no consensus on amending it. She said the bill must proceed as it stands, with amendments to follow later. The effect of the proposed legislation is uncertain, given uncertainty over whether the Hague court will indict anyone else.
Background to the law
The amended law was initiated by the opposition Democratic Party of Kosovo after the Hague-based war crimes court convicted its ex-leader Hashim Thaci and three other wartime Kosovo Liberation Army officials. The four were convicted of the war crimes of arbitrary detention, cruel treatment, torture and murder. Thaci and Jakup Krasniqi were each sentenced to 25 years in prison, Kadri Veseli received 18 years, and Rexhep Selimi received 13 years; an appeal is expected.
MPs initially voted for the amended law on October 6 in a rushed procedure. They did so under pressure from protests that turned violent outside the parliament building and the need to push through the urgent last-minute election of Kosovo's new president. The vote followed weeks of protests after the convictions, and the new president's election was needed to avoid a political crisis of almost two years.
The Kosovo Specialist Chambers is a hybrid court in The Hague, staffed by internationals, that is part of Kosovo's judiciary. It was established in 2015 to try former Kosovo Liberation Army fighters, under pressure from Kosovo's Western allies.