Susan Smith was denied parole by a seven-person parole board in Columbia, South Carolina, on Thursday, November 19, 2026. The board voted unanimously to deny her request to be freed. It was the second time she has been denied parole. The board also unanimously denied her request in 2024. The denial came 32 years after she drowned her sons in a lake.
Under South Carolina law at the time of her sentence, Smith could ask for parole after 30 years and, if refused, every two years after that. Release required two-thirds of the board members present to vote in her favor. The board granted parole in only 4% of cases before it, and most of those granted were non-violent cases.
The hearing was held virtually, with Smith joining by video call from prison. Smith said she was not the same person she was 32 years ago and that she was very, very sorry. She said she would go back and change the circumstances if she could. She also said she has great remorse for killing her sons and asked the board to give her a chance to get out of prison. Psychologist Jessie Hill said Smith's serious mental illness has been greatly subdued thanks to medicine, hormonal changes from menopause, and the deaths of her mother and stepfather.
David Smith, the boys' father and Smith's ex-husband, attended the hearing to advocate for his sons and pleaded with the board to keep her in prison. He testified that she killed the boys deliberately. He said granting parole would be a huge injustice to Michael and Alex. He vowed to oppose her release for as long as he can.
Smith was convicted of killing her two sons by strapping them into their car seats and rolling her vehicle into a lake in 1994. She was sentenced to life in prison for the drownings of 3-year-old Michael and 14-month-old Alex, after the jury chose not to give her the death penalty. For nine days in 1994, she insisted that a Black carjacker had driven away with her sons, who were at the bottom of John D. Long Lake in Union County, South Carolina. She eventually confessed. The boys' bodies were found dangling upside-down in their car seats.
Prosecutors argued that Smith killed the boys after a man with whom she was having an affair told her they were the reason the pair had no future together. At trial, Smith and her attorneys blamed her mental health. They said she planned to go into the lake with her sons but changed her mind at the last moment. A re-creation by investigators showed it took six minutes for her Mazda to dip below the surface of the lake.